2024's Ghostlight was a favorite of mine, a sneak up on you weeper about a construction worker (Keith Kupferer) who turns to the stage after a personal tragedy. This film, Mouse, is also co-directed by Kelly O'Sullivan and Alex Thompson based off a script by O'Sullivan. It returns us to grief, perhaps more intensely so, this time putting Katherine Mallen Kupferer in the spotlight as Minnie. Minnie is on the cusp of her high school senior year when we meet her alongside BFF Callie (Chloe Coleman). Minnie is the wind between Callie's wings, though to see the two together you'd barely recognize how incredibly different they are.
It doesn't take long to realize that without Callie, Minnie would be an outsider. Their friendship feels genuine. We buy into it completely. It doesn't matter that the two are so completely different; they are friends. That's all that matters.
Mouse, first of all, captures the weirdness that occurs when tragedy strikes. One day we're happy, the next day we're shell-shocked by the trauma of loss and grief.
In terms of its rawness, Mouse left me feeling much like I did after watching Rabbit Hole. There aren't a lot of truly great films about grief, or at least not very many ones that feel truthful and honesty. Mouse always feels truthful and honest, O'Sullivan's script somehow striking a beautiful balance between the gut-punch of grief and the truth that somehow our lives go on. It is into this mix that we meet Helen (Sophie Okonedo), Callie's mother who has suddenly and irrevocably lost her entire identity.
O'Sullivan's dialogue is somehow filled with both love and loss, aching in its vulnerability yet also recognizing of little shards of light. While it could easily have been a gimmick, Thompson and O'Sullivan have once again placed authenticity into the storytelling by having Tara Mallen, Mallen Kupferer's real-life mother, as her mother in the story. This worked beautifully in Ghostlight. It works beautifully here. Minnie's homelife is chaotic, yet it is never played for drama or histrionics. Minnie's awkward friendship with Okonedo's Helen feels honest yet potentially ill-fated. O'Sullivan is much too wonderful a writer to turn this all into unnecessary drama, instead leaning to the common connection that makes it believable if not particularly healthy.
Mouse is a character-driven film. Indeed, these characters are drawn magnificently. While we get little time with them, Minnie and Callie feel completely lovely together, their compatibilities somehow bridging all of their differences. Mallen Kupferer, so wonderful in Ghostlight, gives an absolute breakout performance here with a a quiet resolved and vulnerability not easily forgotten. Sophie Okonedo? This is very likely my favorite performance of hers, a revelatory turn with a line spoken toward the end of the film that simply left me sobbing. Tara Mallen is once again wonderful, David Hyde Pierce isn't here much but is absolutely memorable, and Iman Vellani is terrific as Kat, a video store clerk for whom Minnie harbors a definite crush.
At right at two hours, Mouse overstays its welcome just a wee bit. Set in 2002, the film's soundtrack is sublimely selected and I can't help but hope that my film journalism peer and pal Nick Rogers captures the film as I can't imagine at least one of the tunes won't land on Rogers' always insightful year-end posting of the best needle-drops.
Mouse is a film about grief, sure. It's also a film about girlhood, friendship, and even expectations. It's a film that's lingering in my psyche, O'Sullivan's storytelling once again hitting all the right notes and brought to life by a truly marvelous ensemble and her co-direction with Thompson. Among the smaller films to really land a major impact this year, Mouse is for sure worthy of your attention as we head toward awards season.
Written by Richard Propes
The Independent Critic