If you are expecting Poh Si Teng's American Doctor to be a sanitized view of Gaza, you will likely want to amend your expectations before sitting down with the director's feature directorial debut. American Doctor is also not a film that idolizes its key subjects, though it is hard, perhaps impossible, to not marvel at them. Those subjects - North Carolina's Dr. Mark Perlmutter, emergency physician Dr. Thaer Ahmad, and general/critical care surgeon Dr. Feroze Sidhwa - are absolutely riveting.
Still, they are not the reason we are here.
It seems appropriate that I sat down with American Doctor on Halloween, because there are few films this year likely to be more jarring and frightening than the remarkable American Doctor.
Teng, who produced the Oscar-nominated Saving Superman, follows this trio of physicians as they travel to Gaza to Nasser Hospital where they will practice medicine during what is, quite simply, a genocide of epic proportions and one which has, against all rules of war, intensely targeted children, journalists, and healthcare workers.
There's a relentless urgency here, not only the unfolding situation but the fact that so much of what happens here occurred during 2024 and especially 2025.
We are in the first moments of the film when we are slammed, and slammed hard, as Dr. Perlmutter is sharing with the filmmaker photographs of young children who had been killed by Israeli bombs in Gaza. At first, Teng expresses an intent to blur the photos. Dr. Perlmutter is aghast. It is a filmmaker/subject confrontation with some degree of force. In the end, Perlmutter's intense comeback wins out and the photos, difficult to see, are shown unblurred.
Expect this throughout American Doctor.
The three physicians have different cultural backgrounds and personalities. Perlmutter is Jewish, a man with a fiery personality whose views somewhat rage at the screen throughout the film's 93-minute running time. That said, he's thoughtful, compassionate, and incredibly devoted. Ahmad is a Palestinian-American, a fact that will keep him time and again from being approved by Israeli authorities to enter Gaza. Sidhwa is, at least personality wise, a polar opposite of Perlmutter. He's calm, cool, and collected and his eyes light up when he's working with children. He's a secular Pakistani-American, guided by his humanitarianism rather than cultural or religious affiliation.
We get to know each of them not just in Gaza, but also in their homes and workplaces. They speak for themselves. Their tones may vary, but their resolves create a tapestry of commitment and determination.
Both Perlmutter and Sidhwa arrive in Gaza during what is called a ceasefire. Located in the city of Khan Younis, Nasser Hospital and its surroundings are not under attack when the two physicians arrive. However, it quickly becomes apparent that the ceasefire is regularly violated and ultimately even this hospital will not be a safe haven for anyone for long. While I may have connected more with Sidhwa, there are scenes here in which Perlmutter's humanity is stark and laid bare to leave us speechless.
As is always true within a film such as American Doctor, the human cost is captured onscreen. The production crew is constantly at risk even as they struggle with their own lives and families. They are all taking tremendous risks to share these stories.
Time and again, these physicians butt heads with disbelieving Americans and media. They are relentless in their revelations regarding deliberate attacks on children, and one can feel their palpable rage as journalists offer disclaimers about "unprorven allegations" while speaking to the healthcare workers who are physically present amidst it all.
American Doctor, in many ways, reminded me of the remarkable For Sama. This is a film that I also have no doubt will be remembered come awards season. That's hardly the point, of course, but perhaps such recognition will allow the film's visibility to increase for this difficult to watch but absolutely necessary to see film.
To say that I enjoyed American Doctor would be false. I didn't enjoy a minute of it. American Doctor isn't the kind of film you enjoy. American Doctor is the kind of film your memory clings to and refuses to forget. It's the kind of film that alters your DNA and demands your attention. It's the kind of film that calls you into action and dares you to look away.
Don't you dare look away.
Written by Richard Propes
The Independent Critic